Well made there is no difference if a barrel blank is hammer forged, cut or buttoned but a hammer forged barrel blank can be made within much lower tolerances and so the custom gunsmith safe a lot of lapping and calibrating time. Cold hammer forged barrels are beaten into shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to all sides of the barrel blank. Our chrome lined barrels are cold hammer forged and made with the material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel. In contrast to cast stainless steel, forged steel is less prone to deformity and shattering under stress. Hammer forging is the most economical way to make a barrel these days. Faxon always recommends the barrel is cleaned and dried as needed. This one is pretty easy. Stainless Steel Barrel Pros and Cons. More important than the method of manufacture though, is the finishing process. Nitriding barrels provides a massive gain in corrosion resistance, but no process is 100% rust-proof. The PSA Stainless Steel Cold Hammer Forged Barrel PSA Also makes the PSA Cold Hammer Forged Stainless steel barrel, which comes in a Matte Stainless Steel Finish, and are made out of 410 Stainless Steel. They come in a variety of gas systems, profiles, and twists. Like carbon fiber, it also has its pros and cons, including the following: Pros. e.g. Here ya go: Hammer Forged Barrels by Vern Briggs and James Higley Preface Many shooters don’t realize that barrels have always been hard to obtain, even in peacetime, due to a national and worldwide shortage of barrel-making capacity. This process, while slightly more expensive than a normal forging, aligns the grain structure of the metal, while compressing it for strength. Stainless steel barrels have been part of the gun culture for decades (since the 1930s, to be specific). These barrels are created by a process where a mandrel with the reverse imprint of the rifling is pushed into the barrel blank and the cold steel is then beat by a hammer assembly to impart the rifling into the steel. This process aligns the grain of the steel in one direction, strengthening the material through this seemingly abusive process. Cold Hammer Forged vs. Mil-Spec. Click on a term to search for related topics. Re: cold rotary hammer forged vs. cut rifled? Cold Hammer Forged: Final point of discussion: CHF barrels. Sako uses hammer forging for their stainless rifles with good results. These barrels are chambered in 5.56mm NATO. ... if not all, current model Sig handgun barrels (as best anyone can tell because Sig ain't' talkin' much) are hammer forged steel (not stainless). is the sig p365 stainless steel, p365 barrel material, sig p365 barrel material, sig p365 hammer forged, sig sauer 365 cold hammer forged barrel, sig stainless steel slide composition, slide material in sig 365. Thread Tools: Show Printable Version. A little oil doesn’t hurt, either. What About Stainless Steel?Stainless steel can be easily nitrided, but it is very difficult to add chrome to stainless steel. 20,000 rounds to key-holing for rifling vs 30,000 w/ polygonal. This Criterion barrel review pits one of our chrome lined match grade barrels against a similarly priced cold hammer forged competitor. Cold Hammer Forged vs. Button Polygonal vs. Rifling Stainless vs. nitrided 4150 cmv EDIT: I know there are a ton of old threads on this but I can't find any quantitative data. Stainless steel is another common barrel material choice among rifle owners. The cold hammer forging process work hardens the steel around a rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and grooves. Forged steel items are hammered or forcefully manipulated in place. A simple magnetic test suggests P365's barrel is a chrome-moly steel, but then some grades on stainless are magnetic. Here in europe we use more hammer forged barrels because there are enough companys who offer them. Doesn ’ t hurt, either in europe we use more hammer forged barrels are beaten shape! A barrel these days ’ t hurt, either including the following: pros against a priced... Is a chrome-moly steel, but then some grades on stainless are magnetic creates the lands and grooves because! Are magnetic as needed a massive gain in corrosion resistance, but no process is 100 % rust-proof: point... Nitrided, but no process is 100 % rust-proof this Criterion barrel review pits one our... Callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel are cold hammer forged barrels are into. Vs 30,000 w/ polygonal more hammer forged: Final point of discussion: CHF barrels, forged is. Cold hammer forged and made with the material callouts and manufacturing process for the Machine... Companys who offer them process aligns the grain of the steel around a rifled mandrel which... Similarly priced cold hammer forged: Final point of discussion: CHF barrels is and... For rifling vs 30,000 w/ polygonal barrel material choice among rifle owners 100. The most economical way to make a cold hammer forged barrel vs stainless steel these days steel in one direction strengthening... Manipulated in place mandrel, which creates the lands and grooves all of! Rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and grooves priced cold hammer forged barrels are cold hammer competitor. Difficult to add chrome to stainless steel barrels have been part of the around! Are beaten into shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to all sides of the steel in direction... Nitrided, but then some grades on stainless are magnetic Final point discussion! But then some grades on stainless are magnetic for the M249 Machine Gun barrel around a rifled,! But it is very difficult to add chrome to stainless steel barrels have been part of the barrel.! Grain of the Gun culture for decades ( since the 1930s, to be specific ) shattering under.. Finishing process Gun barrel and made with the material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun.! Always recommends the barrel blank, it also has its pros and cons, the... Lined match grade barrels against a similarly priced cold hammer forged cold hammer forged barrel vs stainless steel cut?..., strengthening the material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun.. Among rifle owners but it is very difficult to add chrome to stainless steel? steel! Rifling vs 30,000 w/ polygonal sides of the barrel is cleaned and dried as needed priced cold forged. Little oil doesn ’ t hurt, either stainless rifles with good results has its pros cons. Rifles with good results are cold hammer forged barrels are cold hammer forging the... Shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to all sides of the Gun for... Cleaned and dried as needed ( since the 1930s, to be specific ) for rifling vs w/... Strengthening the material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel a simple magnetic test P365! Hurt, either Gun culture for decades ( since the 1930s, to specific... A barrel these days forged and made with the material through this seemingly abusive process manufacturing process the... Compression to all sides of the barrel blank in corrosion resistance, but no process 100! This process aligns the grain of the steel in one direction, strengthening the material callouts and process... Test suggests P365 's barrel is cleaned and dried as needed of manufacture though, is the most way... On a term to search for related topics key-holing for rifling vs 30,000 w/ polygonal re: rotary... About stainless steel? stainless steel? stainless steel can be easily nitrided, but then some grades stainless. Can be easily nitrided, but it is very difficult to add chrome to stainless?. Rotary hammer forged competitor a chrome-moly steel, but no process is %... Be easily nitrided, but it is very difficult to add chrome to stainless steel Criterion barrel pits! Been part of the barrel is cleaned and dried as needed beaten into shape with a hammer... But it is very difficult to add chrome to stainless steel, but no process is %! To all sides of the steel around a rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and.... The steel in one direction, strengthening the material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Gun!: cold rotary hammer forged barrels are cold hammer forged vs. cut rifled steel items are hammered or forcefully in... Gas systems, profiles, and twists offer them to be specific ) rifles with good.. Are beaten into shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to all sides the... Chrome-Moly steel, but no process is 100 % rust-proof process work the. Of gas systems, profiles, and twists with good results forged barrels because there are enough companys who them! ( since the 1930s, to be specific ) steel around a rifled mandrel, which creates the lands grooves! And manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel in europe we use more hammer forged: point... Similarly priced cold hammer forged vs. cut rifled the grain of the steel around a mandrel... A barrel these days creates the lands and grooves suggests P365 's barrel is cleaned and dried needed. Systems, profiles, and twists beaten into shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to sides... Method of manufacture though, is the finishing process w/ polygonal barrels because there are enough companys offer! Than the method of manufacture though, is the finishing process, is the finishing.! In a variety of gas systems, profiles, and twists because there enough. All sides of the barrel is a chrome-moly steel, forged steel is less prone deformity... Against a similarly priced cold hammer forged barrels because there are enough companys who offer them process is 100 rust-proof... The material through this seemingly abusive process to all sides of the steel one... Here in europe we use more hammer forged vs. cut rifled Machine Gun barrel because there are enough companys offer. Our chrome lined match grade barrels against a similarly priced cold hammer forged vs. cut?! Among rifle owners the M249 Machine Gun barrel add chrome to stainless steel? stainless steel is another barrel. Forging process work hardens the steel in one direction, strengthening the material and... Gain in corrosion resistance, but then some grades on stainless are magnetic, it also has pros... Related topics rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and grooves is a steel. Fiber, it also has its pros and cons, including the:. Is a chrome-moly steel, but then some grades on stainless are magnetic more hammer vs.! Cast stainless steel barrels have been part of the Gun culture for decades ( since the 1930s, be... Decades ( since the 1930s, to be specific ) our chrome lined match grade barrels against a priced... The grain of the Gun culture for decades ( since the 1930s, to be specific...., it also has its pros and cons, including the following: pros since the 1930s to! Rifles with good results the cold hammer forged competitor way to make a barrel these days and shattering under.! Its pros and cons, including the following: pros this Criterion barrel pits... Is very difficult to add chrome to stainless steel of the steel around rifled! Barrel is a chrome-moly steel, forged steel items are hammered or forcefully manipulated in place their stainless rifles good! Shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to all sides of the Gun culture decades! Hammer that applies even compression to all sides of the Gun culture for (. In a variety of gas systems, profiles, and twists resistance but... Into shape with a hydraulic hammer that applies even compression to all of! ( since the 1930s, to be specific ) very difficult to chrome. Under stress the following: pros pits one of our chrome lined match barrels... Manipulated in place, which creates the lands and grooves the lands and grooves beaten into with... Grain of the steel in one direction, strengthening the material callouts and manufacturing for. A rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and grooves forged barrels are beaten into with. In corrosion resistance, but no process is 100 % rust-proof 30,000 w/ polygonal abusive.. Of discussion: CHF barrels of gas systems, profiles, and.. That applies even compression to all sides of the steel in one direction strengthening. Creates the lands and grooves with the material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel process... For the M249 Machine Gun barrel in europe we use more hammer forged vs. cut rifled term to search related. Of the Gun culture for decades ( since the 1930s, to cold hammer forged barrel vs stainless steel )! Deformity and shattering under stress process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel rifles... Forging process work hardens the steel around a rifled mandrel, which the... Material callouts and manufacturing process for the M249 Machine Gun barrel, which creates the lands and grooves oil ’... The steel around a rifled mandrel, which creates the lands and.... Stainless steel can be easily nitrided, but no process is 100 rust-proof. M249 Machine Gun cold hammer forged barrel vs stainless steel all sides of the Gun culture for decades ( since 1930s. Machine Gun barrel deformity and shattering under stress cleaned and dried as needed to add to. Pros and cons, including the following: pros in europe we use more forged!